FAQs based on the City's standard presentation for all CIDs

Some people talk about CIDs, and others talk about SRAs - what's the difference?

Community Improvement Districts (CIDs) and Special Rating Areas (SRAs) are the same thing!   The original legislation referred to SRAs so, even though everyone now calls them CIDs, policy documents have to keep using the term SRA to accurately reflect the law......

What is a CID? 

It refers to a clearly defined geographical area, in which property owners contribute additional rates to fund ‘top-up’ services for that specific area as per the approved Business Plan. 

What is the regulatory framework governing CIDs? 

CIDs are governed by Section 22 of the Municipal Property Rates Act (MPRA), the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA), the Companies Act (Non Profit Company - NPC), the SA Constitution and the City of Cape Town’s Special Rating Area By-law of 2012. 

These laws refer to Special Rating Areas (SRAs) which is the formal, legal name for CID.

Why establish an CID? 

According to the SA Constitution (Sections 152 and 153), the objective of a local authority is to provide all its residents with certain basic services such as water, electricity, sanitation and refuse removal, etc. – up to an equitable standard. For communities who wish to enjoy municipal services of a higher level, an SRA provides them with the option of paying for these additional services, which should be affordable and sustainable. 

What types of ‘top-up’ services are provided in a CID? 

Typically, these would be services dealing with Urban Management issues like additional public safety measures, cleansing services, maintenance of infrastructure, upgrading of the environment, and social services, etc. 

Does the formation of an CID mean that the City can reduce the level and quality of its services? 

No. The City is obligated to sustain existing service levels and to provide basic services as per the Constitution. Each CID will engage with the various service departments regarding the level of services to be provided by the municipality. This enables the CID to decide on the ‘top-up’ services required. 

What are the benefits for CID members?

By combining their resources in a CID, individual property owners can enjoy the collective benefits of a well-managed area, a shared sense of communal pride, safety and social responsibility, and access to joint initiatives such as waste recycling, energy-efficiency programs, etc. In the end, these all translate into a tangible boost in property values and capital investments. 

Are there different types of CID? 

No, but an SRA can consist of industrial, commercial and residential components, or a combination of all three. 

How many CIDs are there in Cape Town? 

At the time of writing there were 47 CIDs in the City of Cape Town. A number of others were applying for establishment - a process that takes up to two years. 

How does one establish an CID? 

An CID is always initiated by a community, and not by the City. It usually starts with ‘champions’ within a community who feel the necessity to improve the environment within a defined area. They then compile a five-year business plan (including the motivation report, the implementation plan and a budget) indicating how the improvements are to be achieved, and present this to the community at a public meeting. 

Thereafter property owners are lobbied for their support where a majority (more than 50% in an area classified as commercial and more than 60% for an area classified as residential) has to give written consent to the formation of a CID. Once this has been obtained, the steering group has to submit an application to the City. The application is then advertised in the media and property owners are also notified to allow them time to render any comments or objections. 

The City then considers the application with the objections at a full sitting of Council. After the City has approved the application, a NPC is set up and a board is elected. The NPC has to register for VAT, open a bank account and be registered as a vendor with the City, etc. This must all be in place before the City makes any payment to the CID.   The first time that additional rates levies could be due is in July 2024.

Who manages the CID? 

A CID is a Non-Profit Company (NPC) managed by a board elected by its members, and operated by a management team appointed by the board. Property owners must sign up for NPC membership to allow them to participate in the CID`s affairs. The City is not involved in their day-to-day operations, but merely exercises financial oversight and legal compliance. 

Who monitors the finances? 

A CID is governed by the Companies Act (71 of 2008) and manages its own finances and appoints its own auditors. The audited financial statements form part of the City’s consolidated accounts, which are reviewed by the Auditor-General. In addition, monthly financial reports are submitted to the City to monitor and to ensure that expenditure is incurred according to the budget. All CIDs have to submit the Chairman`s report and AFS to the relevant Subcouncil, within two months of their AGM, for noting. 

How is an CID funded? 

A CID is funded from the additional rates paid by property owners within the boundary of the CID. It does not receive any grants or subsidies from the City, but does have the powers to raise additional income. 

Unlike your current rates obligations, every single rand raised by the CID levy will be brought back to our area and spent for the benefit of our neighbourhood. 

The process is completely transparent.  Financial reports are submitted to the CID Board and the City every month, the company’s figures must be audited and all financial statements are published online. 

How are the CID additional rates calculated? 

The CID management confirms the properties within the boundaries of the CID, which is then linked by the City to the municipal valuations according to the most recent general valuation roll. The CID management annually prepares an overall budget for the year. This is based on the specific needs of the area as set out in the approved Business Plan. Individual contributions are then calculated by dividing up the budget total according to the municipal valuations of each property, proportional to the total valuation of the CID. 

The CID Policy allows for a differentiation in tariffs for the different types of properties – be it residential, commercial or industrial. This tariff is then expressed as a Rand in the rand and is applicable over a financial year, which starts on 1 July.  The CID budget and proposed tariff have to be approved by the City, and advertised for comments and objections as part of the City’s budget process prior to implementation on 1 July. 

How are the CID additional rates collected? 

The City collects the additional rates on behalf of the CID. It does not go to the City, although they share an invoice to save on collection costs. The additional rate appears as a separate item (improvement district) on the monthly municipal account of each property owner liable to pay the CID additional rates within the CID. 

What happens to the difference between the actual billing and the pay-over? 

The City pays the CID a monthly amount equivalent to one-twelfth of its approved budget less 3% as a provision for bad debts. The provision for bad debts is kept in a ring-fenced account for the CID. At the end of the financial year the City reconciles the billing with the CID budget pay overs and any under or over billing is offset against the accumulated bad debt account. This account is subsequently compared with the arrears as at the end of the financial year. When the latter is less than the accumulated bad debts, 75% of the difference is paid to the CID as per the Finance Agreement concluded between the City and the CID. 

Is the payment of the additional rates mandatory for all properties within the CID? 

Yes. Once the City has approved a CID, the participation of all property owners liable to pay the CID additional rates, within the boundaries of the CID, is mandatory. However, there are exceptions in terms of relief. 

Who can be exempted from paying the CID additional rates? 

The following categories of owners / properties will be 100% exempted as per the CID Policy:  

• Indigent, Senior Citizens and Disabled Persons who meet the criteria for rates relief  

• Properties registered in the name of and used primarily as a place of worship  

• Council owned properties used predominantly for official municipal business  

• Other properties who qualify for rates relief/exemption as per the City’s Rates Policy 

How does the CID set its budget? 

The CID sets its own budget according to input from its members as per the approved five-year Business Plan. The City does not get involved in this process. Each year, the CID board has to submit a detailed budget to the City by 31 January. The proposed budget may not deviate materially from the approved business plan. If there is a material deviation, an application in terms of Section 11 of the CID By-Law is required. The City evaluates the proposed budget for affordability and sustainability. 

As a non-profit, the CID has ‘Members’ instead of shareholders. All qualifying property owners can become Members of the CID and they elect the Board and approve the annual budget. This is a highly localised enterprise.

What if the valuation base changes within a financial year? 

The valuation base is a snapshot at a point in time (end February) and is used to calculate the additional rate (Rand-in-the-rand) for the following financial year. However, municipal valuations can change within a financial year due to interim valuations, Valuation Court rulings, sub-divisions, Special Rating Areas, Compliance rezoning or other technical adjustments. Should the valuation base decrease or increase substantially, the City must inform the CID in order to recalculate the CID's additional rate. 

Can my CID additional rates be spent anywhere in the City? 

No, it is ring-fenced to be reinvested back exclusively into the CID. 

How does the City resolve additional rates arrears? 

Defaulters are subject to the City’s credit control and debt collection policies. As such, they can have their water and electricity services suspended or their clearance certificates withheld. 

Do members have a say in an CID? 

Absolutely! Every property owner within the CID should apply in writing to the CID Board for membership of the NPC. Only then are they able to participate in CID affairs.